Baked fresh to order & delivered to your doorstep!

We've got a heavenly assortment of muffins and crumb cakes to choose from.
Everything is fresh-baked, from scratch. Even better, we'll ship them right
to you. Delicious and hassle-free! Order online today!

0 item(s) in Cart


Answers to some frequently asked questions

Here are some of our most commonly-asked questions. If you have a question or problem that is not addressed here, please contact us at and our team will get back to you as soon as possible!

Where do you deliver?

We deliver to residential and commercial addresses (no PO Boxes, please) in the continental USA. Please view our shipping and delivery policies for more information.

Can I specify when I want my muffins to be delivered?

Please put your delivery requests in the “Order Notes” section during checkout — we do our very best to accommodate all delivery date requests.

I live on Long Island; do you offer local pickup?

Absolutely! Choose the “local pickup” option when placing your order and you can pick them up in-store! Please be aware that our normal processing time still applies, however. Orders made after 10am will be processed the next day. To buy individual muffins immediately (not boxed or shrink-wrapped) please visit us at Stuff A Bagel/Main Street Caterers (234 Main Street in Farmingdale).

How do you keep your muffins fresh during shipping?

We have spent a lot of time specially designing our packaging to be sure it maintains the freshness of our muffins. Each muffin is baked to order right before your chosen shipping date, cooled and then individually sealed.

For delivery destinations outside of the tri-state area, we do recommend overnight shipping to ensure the best possible quality, since our muffins are perishable and free of preservatives. Please read our shipping policies before placing your order.

Do you have any vegan or gluten-free flavors?

We don’t currently offer any vegan or gluten-free flavors that will stay moist during shipping — but this is something we’re working on developing. Offering some healthier options is a high priority for us — please drop us an email to be notified when we have new flavors available!